The Making of The Celine Archive Movie

Editor’s Note: In celebration of Filipinx American History Month, scholar and filmmaker Celine Parreñas Shimizu discusses her new film, The Celine Archive, set for international release October 15th THE MAKING OF THE CELINE ARCHIVE MOVIE by Celine Parreñas Shimizu Celine Navarro, a 28-year old immigrant mother of four, was buried alive by her Filipinx American community in Northern California in 1932. When I first encountered her story in the 1990s, not much was known about Filipinx American women in the earlier 20th century. Scholars attributed the lack of attention paid to women to sheer numbers. They were outnumbered by men at 1:14 among a new California population thirty to forty thousand strong in the 1920s and 1930s. Today, Filipinx are the largest Asian American group in California. What does it mean for Californians not to know her story? What does it mean that she is unknown by women interested in fathoming the lives of our pioneering foremothers? When we were undergraduates at Berkeley in the 1990s, my sister Rhacel Parreñas, now a renowned sociologist, found Celine’s story in the Bancroft Library archives while researching white women considered “trash’ and Filipinx men regarded as “brown monkeys” in the earlier 20th century. These two marginalized groups forged alliance in the taxi dance halls when Filipinx were lynched and their rooming houses torched in towns like Stockton, where they were segregated from whites. Eugenics and anti-miscegenation laws meant their interracial ties could lead to death. Filipinx American history, dominated by men, meant finding Celine in the archives was rare, particularly a Filipinx immigrant woman with the French name we share. For years, my sister would tease me, saying that this woman with my name is a ghost haunting me in particular. As immigrants ourselves, we carried in us the particularly frightening myths about Filipinx female ghosts who fly around with impaled bodies, attacking people at night. I encountered this thread of Celine Navarro as a ghost beyond my own family. I would meet others in the Filipinx community in California who told me they experienced Celine’s story as a fearsome tale told during bedtime rituals. Filipinx Americans growing up in the Central Valley would come across old-timers whispering about a woman buried alive, with her hand sticking out of the ground. Accounts of a disheveled and dirty woman clad in white, walking the Sacramento Delta’s rugged roadways arose. Hers was seemingly an eerie malevolent ghost story that traveled to California in the Filipinx diaspora. I began to collect paintings of Filipinx female ghosts as a tribute to her. Daring to look at them, I trained myself to confront rather than fear her story. As a filmmaker and a film scholar working on gender, race, sexuality, and transnationalism, Celine Navarro’s story stayed with me for more than two decades as a movie I wanted to make. I began scouring the archives myself while a professor at the University of California at Santa Barbara. The stories in the archive were vivid and cinematic. A group of Filipinx women and men accused her of adultery and kidnapped her, made her crawl on beans, then picked stones out of a bag to decide who would start throwing them at her. Celine and her husband were part of the fraternal organization that killed her. The membership records document all their names together on the rosters. News of the trial of Celine Navarro’s indicted killers traveled the world from Los Angeles to New York to London and Singapore. Fascination about the growing number of Filipinx in America fueled interest in her story because the debates about their inability to assimilate dominated the era. The media reflected a national fear of Filipinx and their essential otherness: headlines used words like voodoo ritual, strange cult, weird trial, jungle justice, and kangaroo court. The primary story that emerged across global media was one of her as an adulteress who betrayed her sick husband, then perversely punished by a bizarre community who considered her a traitor to their moral code. Was she a wanton woman who followed her own code, picking from the plentiful abundance of men, and thus deserved punishment? The group accused of killing her was acquitted. I learned that the organization collected funds from their members to defend her indicted killers. They defended them within the context of disproving their perceived incompatibility with citizenship, sacrificing not only Celine’s life but her very story. Little did I know that Celine Navarro herself traveled to nearby Ventura right before she died, visited her sisters and told them about her fraught life. I would drive by the La Conchita neighborhood where they lived, not knowing such an important part of her story transpired there. In the audio recordings, her sisters shared how Celine was hunted down by a man who desired her and whose wife hated her. Celine’s husband encouraged her to comply. According to her sisters, she was not an adulteress or a traitor but prey: a “scaredy-cat, timid girl” neglected by her husband. Scholars disclosed that she was a heroine, a pioneer of the #metoo movement, in how she testified against a group of men who beat up another man for protecting a white woman from her husband, a known abuser in the community. Her testimony sent four Filipinx men to San Quentin, gaining the community’s ire, for they were determined to uphold loyalty and secrecy during a time of intense racial ostracism. How does this story of her heroic courage reconcile with her as an adulteress, traitor, victim, or prey? And how do these different versions matter in her story? Celine’s own family remembers her sacrifice: she was killed unjustly by her community and how her own choices made theirs happen. While Celine’s sisters lived long lives, I did not meet them. Through the film, I met her family, who fervently honors her today. In 2012, my sister and I were featured speakers at the Los Angeles Echo Park Library at an event attended by hundreds of Filipinx Americans. I talked about my desire to make a film about a woman Celine Navarro and someone in the audience who knew the family approached me. Soon I met Celine Navarro’s niece. Her mother, Celine’s youngest sister, was still alive. My film, originally a narrative drama, became a documentary because I could ask questions about her death’s impact on the people who cared the most. Suddenly, however, my youngest son Lakas, an exuberant, energetic, and loving child, unexpectedly died within 24 hours from a common virus that attacked his heart. Everything changed. Time changed. My world flattened. Around this time, Celine’s youngest sister died too. Since Lakas’ death, the question of how a family who encounters the sudden death of a loved one continues to live, and even thrive, is something I think about every day. How does the next generation remember the loss and feel the transformative suffering that the unexpected death of a loved one brings to the family? As part of my grief work, I began working on the film again, knowing that there are two things I want to achieve. Celine’s story can too easily be told salaciously, and to do so, about a community already criminalized and perverted in history and popular culture would be unjust. I wanted to dig up Celine Navarro’s story to examine intergenerational trauma that would ultimately reconstitute her, flesh her back to life through film. She deserves a place in history that regularly recounts stories about the racism Filipinx encounter but suppresses the sexism the community perpetrates. What is stunning about Celine’s story is how it maps the timeline of Filipinx American history of the last century. Celine arrived in the US in 1918 and up until her death in 1932, traveled regularly between the Philippines and the US at a time of Asian exclusion. Unlike other Asians, Filipinx were considered nationals and provided a leading source of cheap labor. She first dropped her kids in the Philippines as her husband’s condition worsened and her own experiences with the fraternal organization escalated. She was kidnapped and tortured at least twice. The third time was when she returned to Stockton to transport her dying husband. She instead experiences incomprehensibly final brutality. Their kids orphaned, and Filipinx re-classified in 1934’s Tydings-McDuffie Act, her descendants were unable to return until after 1965. Celine’s story also rewrites how we understand and practice belonging within a community. Whenever I see fellow Filipinx Americans, conversations ensue where we try to see if we are related or share the same regional roots or find the best Filipinx place nearby to eat. For Celine’s family, to see other Filipinx is to ask if they were part of the group of people who killed their matriarch, the one who traveled to America and started her American family. Thus, bringing her story and the experiences of her family to light challenges the concept of a cohesive ethnic community. Lastly, Celine’s life shows how women in early Filipinx American history were actional. Her mother Juana Montayre traveled from the Philippines as a widow with three daughters in 1918. Their actions explode the primary narrative that men were the ones who traversed continents to move to the U.S. Celine’s own story, whether adulteress, traitor, heroine, or prey shows she was an actional woman throughout her life. She moved here, lived a life with various versions of bravery and endurance, and finally saved her children before her death. The multitudes that compose her descendants are Filipinx, Black, Latinx, queer, and more—they look like America and are Americans. Celine Navarro’s story is considered a haunting, not by her family who lives with her story, but by Filipinx Americans who keep hush-hush, diminishing the violence she experienced by calling her a ghost, or simply refusing the truths of her story. Celine Navarro sheds light on the experiences of women in Filipinx American history. My new film THE CELINE ARCHIVE is a documentary about one family remembering their loved one, historians and scholars like Alex Fabros, Dorothy Cordova, Dawn Mabalon, Rick Baldoz and community members and cultural workers like Leticia Perez, Dillon Delvo, Jean Vengua and Chris Castro sharing their knowledge to teach a bigger story about Filipinx American lives and the unfinished mysteries that we hold in our collective American story. Racism is not the primary force that structured their community. Within it, misogyny transpired that Celine Navarro’s life and death make known. BIOGRAPHY:  Celine Parreñas Shimizu is Professor and Director of the School of Cinema at San Francisco State University. The award-winning documentary THE CELINE ARCHIVE screens at CAAMFest across California on October 14-18, internationally at the LA Femme International Film Festival on October 15-16, and nationally at the San Diego Asian Film Festival on October 23-31, 2020. It will also screen at the Reel Sisters of the Diaspora: Women of Color Film Festival, among many other national and international film festivals. For more information, please go to www.celinearchive.com. For more information please visit https://celinearchive.wordpress.com/ Release Information: OCTOBER 14-18 Bay Area Premiere: CAAMFestSee a conversation with Director Celine Shimizu, Historian Catherine Choy and Poet Jean Vengua after every screening. Tickets on sale October 5, 2020On-Demand OCTOBER 15 @ 6pm – OCTOBER 16 @ 7:45pm PDTInternational Premiere: LA Femme International Film FestivalOnline | Q&A Event for October 15 at 5pm PDT OCTOBER 23 – 31National Premiere: San Diego Asian Film FestivalOnline

Beauty Diplomacy

It is easy to dismiss beauty pageants as sexist or inconsequential. After all, many pageants continue to make judgments and enforce rules based on women’s body measurements, age, and marital status. Oluwakemi M. Balogun’s Beauty Diplomacy: Embodying an Emerging Nation, however, examines beauty pageants in their full complexity by recognizing aspects of pageantry that some scholars deem troublesome while simultaneously honing-in on the industry’s role in diplomacy, nationalism, and international politics. Set in Nigeria, the fastest-growing economy in Africa, beauty queens emerge as role models of the nation. Tracking the effects of economic globalization, cultural politics, and gendered power, while remaining attuned to contestants’ interpretations of events, Balogun skillfully illuminates how “beauty diplomacy” shapes Nigeria’s stance in the global economy through the strategic position of women who partake in beauty pageants. In 2001, Agbani Darego of Nigeria was the first Black African to win the Miss World pageant. The achievement initiated a series of events that set the stage for the study. Balogun’s personal interest burgeoned during a visit to Nigeria where she encountered countless advertisements promoting one of over 1,000 beauty pageants held annually in the country. To carry out the project, starting in 2009, Balogun spent eleven months in Nigeria whilst working behind-the-scenes as an unpaid intern for The Most Beautiful Girl in Nigeria (MBGN) and as a chaperone for Queen Nigeria where she interviewed owners, organizers, producers, corporate sponsors, contestants, judges, and critics. Outside of the pageant settings, Balogun interviewed makeup artists, journalists, production crew, photographers, fashion designers, and fans. Balogun grounds Beauty Diplomacy in the context of Nigeria’s strained reputation in the global economy. Most people are familiar with Nigerian-based email phishing scams or similar business-investment schemes. Stories linking fraud to Nigeria continually circulate in international media, tarnishing its character and standing. When the United States issued travel advisories from 1993 to 2000, cautioning passengers about criminal activity in Nigeria, it resulted in declining tourism revenue, and thus put a dent in the economy. Agbani Darego’s 2001 Miss World victory allowed officials to mend the nation’s tainted reputation and establish itself as an important member of the international community, a process Balogun describes as “redemptive politics” (9). Various organizations parlayed her win to advance a new image of the nation. For instance, the Nigerian Tourism Development Corporation (NTDC) invited Darego to multiple exhibits in Europe and the United States that featured large photographs of her wearing the Miss World crown along with images of prominent tourist locations in Nigeria, while the Nigerian Postal Service (NIPOST) issued stamps commemorating her victory. As these examples illustrate, women’s bodies not only “symbolically stand-in for the nation,” but elevate its profile and materially integrate it “into the global economy” (13). Beauty pageants served as focal points for restoring national credibility, helping boost Nigeria’s transition from developing to developed country status. They also helped forge a sense of nationalism. In a country of over 250 ethnic groups, many Nigerians identify with an ethnic or regional identity rather than a national one (39). Nevertheless, beauty queens collectively engage in embodied work to represent a unified sense of Nigeria in an effort to improve Nigeria’s global standing (40). Balogun contextualizes these dynamics using an “African rising realist” approach that acknowledges the opportunities that beauty pageants create for emerging nations while noting the need for additional infrastructural changes before significant demographic and economic advancement can be achieved. Latent instability continues to characterize the region; political uprisings, chronic disease, and famine are still a part of reality despite growing pride for Nigerian music and Nollywood films (5).One of the book’s many strengths is the integration of Nigeria’s colonial and postcolonial history in relation to the structure of pageants. Colonial conditions created vast ethnic and religious diversity within the nation. Culture influences how pageants operate. Some pageants, such as The Most Beautiful Girl in Nigeria (MBGN), take a cosmopolitan-nationalism approach by focusing on cosmopolitan elements of Nigeria to represent the nation as urbane (63), while others, such as Queen Nigeria, appeal to cultural-nationalism by taking a “unity in diversity” approach (66). Despite their distinct approaches, both pageants position their contestants as role models and ambassadors who will restore Nigeria’s image through “embodied” work. Ideas about the nation are created and challenged by centering women’s bodies as stand-ins for Nigeria through beauty pageants (19). Similar to sporting events such as the Olympics and the FIFA World Cup, beauty pageants garner international attention. Yet, they are not treated as equally indispensable. Balogun’s comparison of Nigeria’s approach to Miss World and the FIFA U-17 World Cup demonstrates how diplomacy discourses are often linked to masculinity (19). In 2009, Nigeria successfully hosted FIFA U-17 World Cup, in spite of threats from an armed militant group. The government offered the organization amnesty in exchange for their weapons and the conflict quickly ended. In contrast, plans to host Miss World 2002 resulted in a public relations disaster when the event was moved to London two weeks prior to the scheduled date due to unrest stemming from the mistreatment of women under sharia law. Unlike the strategic response to the FIFA World Cup conflict, growing concerns around safety led Nigeria to prioritize protecting the contestants, rather than navigating the conflict. Balogun’s study illustrates how beauty pageants function differently in developing countries. In addition to boosting a nation’s international reputation and creating a unified sense of nationalism, pageants create business opportunities. In 2014, Nigeria became the largest economy in Africa, surpassing South Africa. And, while oil and gas dominated a large portion of that growth, the service sector grew exponentially as a result of new businesses operated by former beauty queens. Women’s economic contributions, however, remained less recognized by officials, and thus less valued, because of gendered expectations that are associated with international role models. Most notably, Balogun’s study offers a new perspective to discussions surrounding “embodied nationalism”. Although a growing body of research has been done on militarized masculinity to demonstrate how ideas about a nation are created through gendered bodies, Balogun specifically focuses on how beauty diplomacy as a form of embodied nationalist strategy is used to navigate national conflict (42). Beauty Diplomacy similarly makes contributions to the literature around “gendered diplomacy” where women are positioned to serve as political or cultural ambassadors by offering a comparison between the beauty pageant contestants and the influence of first ladies in cultural representation. Balogun’s study on beauty pageants can be applied to other cultural and political events to measure the impact they have on crisis management and a nation’s overall global standing (234). In closing, Beauty Diplomacy makes significant contributions to research on globalization, nationalism, and gender. Much of the Western feminist criticism around beauty pageants continue to deem them oppressive. However, there is a group of scholars who argue that beauty pageants can serve as platforms in which cultural diversity is celebrated where numerous opportunities are made available to women. Balogun’s work connects these views by recognizing the hierarchies of power in pageant settings without classifying them exploitative or empowering, but rather focuses on beauty pageants as sites where ideas about power and difference are revealed (24). Questions about power continue to circulate as developing countries put a heavy emphasis on beauty pageants for growth and recognition, while ultimately countries that are already in a position of power seem to benefit the most from them (231). Balogun’s study gives the readers an insight into the polarizing nature of beauty pageants. As pageants continue to grow in popularity in many countries across the world, so does the criticism against them. Although pageants may no longer solely focus on physical attributes, and contestants are evaluated on civic engagement, women are still expected to remain respectable, pure, and desirable. Traditional gender norms remain enforced even when structural changes are seemingly in place to benefit women. Elegantly written and clearly presented, Beauty Diplomacy would be a welcome addition for undergraduate classes on gender, development, and globalization. Additionally, Balogun’s thorough analysis, grounded in transnational and postcolonial feminist theory, would make the book a fascinating read for graduate seminars on the body, femininities, the nation, and culture.

Gender Politics in Iran and the Last Forty Years: Eleven Stories

Frontiers is pleased to present a special online issue addressing gender politics in Iran in the last forty years following the 1979 Iran Revolution.

You’re Dead – So What?

This book provides an empirical study of media and law enforcement bias in reporting and investigating homicides of African American women compared with their white counterparts. The author discusses the symbiotic relationship between media coverage and the response from law enforcement to victims of color, particularly when these victims are reported missing and presumed to be in danger by their loved ones.

As We Have Always Done

Leanne Betasamosake Simpson locates Indigenous political resurgence as a practice rooted in uniquely Indigenous theorizing, writing, organizing, and thinking. She makes clear that the goal of Indigenous resistance can no longer be cultural resurgence as a mechanism for inclusion in a multicultural mosaic, calling for unapologetic, place-based Indigenous alternatives to the destructive logics of the settler colonial state.

Evidence of Being

Evidence of Being is an important book that should impact the contours of Black and Queer Studies. Bost’s recuperation of the history of black gay cultural expression opens new lines of inquiry for scholars concerned with black sexuality, loss, history, and memory. Readers will find Evidence of Being moving, theoretically rich, and original.

From Angel to Office Worker

Susie S. Porter’s newest monograph, From Angel to Office Worker, Middle-Class Identity and Female Consciousness in Mexico, 1890–1950, is an important piece of scholarship that unapologetically emphasizes that women’s history is labor history and that labor history is women’s history.

Dr. Donna J. Haraway

Listen to Dr. Donna Haraway and Dr. Kimberly Jew’s dialogue on theoretical, methodological, and literary explorations into not only what it means to live as human beings in a multispecies world, but what it could (or, perhaps should) mean in a not-so-distant future.

Sarah Waters: Gender and Sexual Politics

In her book, Claire O’Callaghan inserts herself into the debate between essentialist feminists and queer theorists, reading Waters’ historical fiction as a model for contemporary queer and feminist interdependence.

Eli Erlick

Eli Erlick, author of “Technologizing Gender: Trans Youth Activism on the Internet”, is the director of a national youth-led organization dedicated to transforming the educational environment for trans students, where her work emphasizes transgender youth activism, education, and media.